Tyler, recovering from an injury that could end his career and has him in the dugout coaching a high-stakes softball game against Kenzie, a pretty-faced feisty coach with whom he has history. They don't exactly hit it off in the game opener in which she pitches him some love--competitiveness and love don't mix. They must rekindle their love, learn to forgive and forget, and leave their complicated history behind. Love strikes in different ways when iconic Christian girl Tiffany runs away from her wedding and randomly jumps into the car of free-spirited maverick Chase, who quickly sweeps her off her feet and leaves her questioning her faith and values. Tyler must choose between love and a career, and Kenzie must let go and give him a second chance. Will he choose his baseball career over love? Will she steal his heart, or strike out in the game of love?